In plain words: Classical computers can mimic quantum data loading by sampling data points in proportion to their squared size, allowing fair comparison. Rebuilt this way, quantum principal component analysis and clustering run only polynomially slower classically, so their exponential speedup comes from the data-loading assumption.
Abstract · Quantum principal component analysis only achieves an exponential speedup because of its state preparation assumptions
A central roadblock to analyzing quantum algorithms on quantum states is the lack of a comparable input model for classical algorithms. Inspired by recent work of the author [E. Tang, STOC'19], we introduce such a model, where we assume we can efficiently perform $\ell^2$-norm samples of input data, a natural analogue to quantum algorithms that assume efficient state preparation of classical data. Though this model produces less practical algorithms than the (stronger) standard model of classical computation, it captures versions of many of the features and nuances of quantum linear algebra algorithms. With this model, we describe classical analogues to Lloyd, Mohseni, and Rebentrost's quantum algorithms for principal component analysis [Nat. Phys. 10, 631 (2014)] and nearest-centroid clustering [arXiv:1307.0411]. Since they are only polynomially slower, these algorithms suggest that the exponential speedups of their quantum counterparts are simply an artifact of state preparation assumptions.
Ewin Tang
arXiv:1811.00414 · cs.DS, cs.IR, cs.LG, quant-ph · submitted Oct 31, 2018 · updated Aug 6, 2021
abstract · pdf · html · 6 pages + 7 pages (supplemental material). Title used to be "Quantum-inspired classical algorithms for principal component analysis and supervised clustering"